How to Select the Appropriate Carbon Steel Plate Grade for Specific Requirements

Issuing time:2025-10-09 17:08

The core of selecting a suitable carbon steel plate grade for specific requirements lies in accurately matching the core needs of the actual application scenario (such as mechanical properties, processing methods, environmental adaptability, etc.) with the characteristics of different carbon steel plate grades. Below is a step-by-step selection logic, key considerations, and typical scenario examples to help efficiently identify the right grade.

1. Clarify Core Requirements: First Define the "Non-Negotiable Key Indicators"

Before selection, it is necessary to clarify the most critical constraints of the application scenario to avoid focusing on secondary properties unnecessarily. Priority should be given to confirming the following four categories of key requirements:

1.1 Mechanical Property Requirements

This is the most core indicator, determining whether the carbon steel plate can withstand the loads and environmental stresses during use.

Clarify: Do you need high tensile strength (e.g., load-bearing structures), high yield strength (e.g., deformation-resistant components), good toughness (e.g., low-temperature or impact environments), or just basic strength (e.g., non-load-bearing decorative parts)?
Example: Scaffolding in construction requires "moderate yield strength + easy processability," while buckets of mining machinery require "high tensile strength + high wear resistance."

1.2 Processing Technology Requirements

The processing method of carbon steel plates directly restricts grade selection (different grades vary significantly in weldability, cold/hot formability).

Clarify: Is welding required (e.g., steel structure splicing), cold stamping (e.g., automobile body parts), bending (e.g., equipment enclosures), or heat treatment (e.g., gears that need hardening)?
Example: For bridge structures requiring extensive welding, grades with good weldability must be selected; for hardware parts requiring cold stamping forming, grades with excellent plasticity should be chosen.

1.3 Service Environment Requirements

The environment affects the durability of carbon steel plates, so targeted selection is necessary (carbon steel plates themselves have weak corrosion resistance and need surface treatment, but the basic properties of grades still matter).

Clarify: Is the plate used in a low-temperature environment (e.g., outdoor equipment in northern regions, requiring resistance to low-temperature brittle fracture), humid/slightly corrosive environment (e.g., workshop water tanks, requiring galvanization), or high-temperature environment (e.g., boiler components, requiring heat resistance and stability)?

1.4 Cost and Versatility Requirements

If core properties are met, priority should be given to grades with strong versatility and low procurement costs (to avoid "over-engineering").

Example: Ordinary storage racks do not require high-strength grades; basic general-purpose grades can be used to reduce costs.

2. Match Grade Characteristics: Screen Grades by "Priority of Requirements"

Different carbon steel plate grades are designed for different purposes. Based on the above core requirements, their key characteristics should be matched accordingly. Below is the characteristic and demand-matching logic for the domestic Q-series low/middle carbon steel plates (accounting for over 90% of engineering applications):

Grade	Core Characteristics (Tensile Strength/Yield Strength)	Weldability	Cold Formability	Toughness (Low-Temperature)	Applicable Core Requirement Scenarios
Q235	Basic strength (Tensile: 410-550MPa / Yield: ≥235MPa)	Excellent	Excellent	General (good at room temperature, brittle below -20℃)	1. Non-load-bearing/light-load-bearing structures (e.g., racks, fences, decorative parts); 2. General engineering requiring extensive welding and cold forming (e.g., building purlins, equipment enclosures); 3. Cost-sensitive scenarios with no special environmental requirements.
Q345	Medium-high strength (Tensile: 510-650MPa / Yield: ≥345MPa)	Good	Good	Good (resistant to -40℃)	1. Medium load-bearing structures (e.g., main beams of bridges, columns and beams of steel-structured workshops); 2. Equipment requiring deformation resistance and impact resistance (e.g., crane booms, containers); 3. Low-temperature or outdoor exposed environments (e.g., municipal facilities in northern regions).
Q390	High strength (Tensile: 570-720MPa / Yield: ≥390MPa)	Fair	General	Good (resistant to -40℃)	1. High-strength load-bearing structures (e.g., core columns of high-rise steel structures, large-span trusses); 2. Components bearing dynamic loads (e.g., frames of construction machinery, bases of mining equipment).
Q420/Q460	High strength (Tensile: 630-780MPa / Yield: ≥420/460MPa)	Fair (requires special welding process)	Poor (requires hot forming)	Excellent (resistant to -60℃)	1. Key structures bearing heavy loads and extreme loads (e.g., main towers of large bridges, wind turbine towers); 2. Low-temperature and high-impact environments (e.g., polar equipment, deep-sea platform components); 3. Scenarios requiring weight reduction while ensuring strength (e.g., frames of heavy-duty vehicles).
45# Steel	Medium carbon (Tensile: 600MPa / Yield: ≥355MPa, quench-hardenable)	Poor (prone to cracking)	Poor	General (toughness decreases after quenching)	1. Components requiring local hardening (e.g., gears, shafts, bolts); 2. Mechanical parts requiring hardness improvement via heat treatment (e.g., machine tool spindles, couplings).

3. Avoid Common Misconceptions: Prevent "Overperformance" or "Underperformance"

3.1 Misconception 1: Blindly Pursuing High Grades (Overperformance)

Example: Using Q460 for ordinary storage racks — the strength of Q460 is twice that of Q235, but racks only need basic load-bearing capacity. High-grade plates will increase procurement costs by more than 30% and are more difficult to process (prone to cracking during cold forming).Solution: For non-load-bearing and impact-free scenarios, prioritize Q235; Q345 is sufficient for medium load-bearing.

3.2 Misconception 2: Ignoring Processability (Only Focusing on Strength)

Example: Using 45# steel to weld bridge structures — 45# steel has a high carbon content (0.45%), which is prone to cracking during welding and requires preheating + post-heat treatment. The process cost is extremely high, and the weld strength is difficult to guarantee.Solution: For scenarios requiring welding, high-carbon steels (such as 45# steel) must be avoided; low-carbon steels (Q235, Q345) should be prioritized.

3.3 Misconception 3: Ignoring Low-Temperature Toughness (Outdoor Scenarios in Northern Regions)

Example: Using Q235 for outdoor billboard brackets in northern regions — the toughness of Q235 decreases sharply below -20℃, and it is prone to brittle fracture under wind and snow impact in winter; Q345, however, can withstand -40℃ and has more stable toughness.Solution: When the outdoor ambient temperature is below -10℃, prioritize grades such as Q345 and above (it is necessary to confirm the "low-temperature impact energy" report provided by the manufacturer).

4. Summary: Selection Process (3 Steps to Quickly Identify the Right Grade)

Define core requirements: Clarify 1-2 key indicators among "strength/processing/environment" (e.g., "welding + medium load-bearing," "low temperature + high strength").
Match grade characteristics: Refer to the table above based on core requirements (e.g., "welding + medium load-bearing" → Q345; "needing hardening + non-welding" → 45# steel).
Verify secondary requirements: Confirm whether the secondary properties of the selected grade meet the needs (such as cost and procurement convenience) and avoid process or environmental incompatibility (e.g., verifying low-temperature toughness for low-temperature scenarios).

Through the above logic, unsuitable grades can be efficiently excluded, and carbon steel plates that not only meet usage requirements but also control costs can be accurately selected. For special scenarios (such as high temperature and high corrosion), further combination with surface treatment (e.g., galvanization, painting) or composite materials (e.g., stainless steel composite plates) is required, but the basic grade selection still needs to follow the above principles.

Share to：